3 Stars – Thought-Provoking
What do you do when you are desperate and have the generational “sickness” of poverty? When the economic systems are predatory and you feel the depression not only financially but emotionally? To what lengths would you go to free your own children from this multi-generational economic and social dysfunction? Those are the moral, ethical and systemic questions addressed in David Mackenzie’s powerful and iconic film Hell or High Water. A masterpiece of symbolic messages and excellen acting, we become immersed in the struggle.
Set in the barren region of West Texas and Oklahoma (though filmed in New Mexico), the story is written by Taylor Sheridan and won the 2012 Black List award. Since his family came from this drought-ridden region and being impacted by an uncle who was a marshal in central Texas for 34 years and forced to retire at 65, his authentic and intimate knowledge of this story is obvious.
The fictional tale concerns the two Howard brothers, Tanner (Ben Foster) and Toby (Chris Pine), whose mother has just passed after a debilitating illness. Tanner, having spent years in prison first for killing their abusive father and then for bank robbery, is invited by his little brother to change the fortunes of his nephews and Toby’s sons. Their plan is to rob the very bank that has been legally robbing their mother of the family ranch through a mortgage. Then pay back the bank with money laundered through a casino and therefore gain the oil money that is going to produce a windfall for generations to come.
The officers who take on the task of finding and arresting these two are an almost-to-retire, recently widowed Texas Ranger named Marcos Hamilton (Jeff Bridges) and his assistant Alberto Parker (Gil Birmingham). Using racial stereotypes to tease Parker for his Native American and Mexican heritage, Hamilton is an inappropriate has-been but with exceptional policing instincts and experience. Widowed and forced into retirement it is clear that Hamilton but with no other purpose than his work and is faltering in his own life.
We won’t spoil how all of this works together to create a powerful piece of art, but the questions still remain at the end of the film. The happy ending of an oil rich discovery is not at all common, so when the poor and powerless are being abused by the very banks and businesses that are populated by their neighbors, how do they survive? The legal profits that are gained by defaulting mortgages on draught-caused farm and ranch losses are unconscionable at a human level and the generational poverty so many people experience is an ever increasing deep hole that no one wants for their children. Addictions and criminal imprisonments are disproportionate to the poor as their despair seeks relief and solutions. How does “justice for all” find its place?
Films like this are a social mirror that haunt us as the artists take us into places and into lives of real people trying to make their way in a very broken world. The fact that there is no church or faith community providing hope and assistance in the film is not indicative of Texas, but its absence makes the story’s dysfunction all the more obvious. It is this absence of a moral and righteous solution that makes this film a powerful, depressing portrayal of life.
- Multi-generational poverty is a primary difficulty in human flourishing. Providing government assistance to just survive in that poverty seems to only reinforce that the next generation remains poor. However, ignoring the need of our fellow human beings is inhumane. What do you think is a possible solution? What could you do to help?
- The absence of hope except through criminal action seems to be accepted by the townspeople in the cafe who are unconcerned that the bank is being robbed and explain that the bank has been robbing them for years. Where do you think a depressed people can find hope? How does that hope become a tangible solution to financial need?
- Do you think most banks are like those portrayed in this West-Texas tale, or are they partners with individuals and businesses in accomplishing prosperity? Why do you answer as you do?